Hogan's Heroes

THE DAY SGT. SCHULTZ LOST MORE THAN HIS DIGNITY

It is funny how a single sound can bring it all back.

I was sitting in this little studio last week, doing a podcast for a classic television network, and the host pulled out this old, grainy black-and-white production still.

It was a photo of John Banner, our beloved Schultz, standing in the middle of the compound with his helmet slightly crooked and a look of absolute, wide-eyed terror on his face.

The host asked me, “Robert, was John really that worried in this scene, or was he just that good of an actor?”

I had to lean back and laugh because that photo wasn’t from a scene that ever made it to air.

It was taken during the filming of an episode in the second season, on a night when the Los Angeles “winter” was actually quite chilly, and we were all exhausted.

You have to understand the dynamic on that set.

We were a group of guys, many of us having survived the actual horrors of the war, playing out this farce every week.

John was a prince of a man, a Jewish refugee himself, and he had this incredible, booming presence that made everyone feel safe.

But John was also a man of a certain carriage, shall we say, and the wardrobe department always had their hands full keeping him in those heavy, wool Greatcoats and those high-waisted trousers.

On this particular night, the director wanted a shot of Schultz discovering LeBeau—that was me—sneaking back into the barracks with a load of stolen supplies.

It was supposed to be one of those rare moments where Schultz actually looked like a formidable soldier of the Third Reich.

He had to run from the guard tower toward the center of the yard, shouting at the top of his lungs for the guards to assemble.

John was determined to get it right because we’d been trailing behind schedule all day.

He took a deep breath, puffed out his chest, and waited for the cue.

The cameras started rolling, the artificial snow was blowing perfectly, and John launched himself into a full-speed sprint.

And then, just as he reached the top of his lungs, something gave way.

The sound was like a whip cracking in a silent canyon.

It wasn’t a small rip or a subtle tear; it was the catastrophic failure of a heavy-duty leather belt and two very stressed buttons at the same time.

John didn’t stop immediately, which made the whole thing ten times worse.

His momentum carried him another five steps, but his trousers stayed exactly where they had been when the belt snapped.

He basically ran right out of his own uniform.

The sight of this giant, legendary man suddenly hobbled at the ankles, wearing these enormous, bright white thermal long johns in the middle of a “grim” Nazi prison camp, was more than any of us could handle.

I was hiding behind a water barrel, supposed to be looking terrified, but I ended up biting my own hand just to keep from screaming with laughter.

The background actors, the guys playing the various German guards who were supposed to be “assembling” with precision, just disintegrated.

One of them actually dropped his prop rifle because he was laughing so hard he lost his grip.

But the best part, the part I will never forget as long as I live, was John’s reaction.

He didn’t fall. He didn’t curse.

He just stopped, looked down at the pile of grey wool around his boots, and then looked directly at the camera with that classic Schultz expression.

He didn’t even drop character.

He just raised his hands, palms out, and said in that thick, beautiful accent, “I see nothing! I see absolutely nothing! Not even my own dignity!”

The director, Gene Reynolds, who was usually a very focused and serious man when we were behind schedule, didn’t even yell “Cut.”

He just leaned his forehead against the monitor and started shaking.

We had to stop filming for nearly an hour.

You can’t just put a man back into his trousers after that and expect the scene to work.

Every time John tried to look “stern” after that, Werner Klemperer—our Klink—would catch my eye and start making a tiny snapping sound with his fingers.

Werner was a serious musician, a very disciplined man, but John Banner was his kryptonite.

Werner would have to turn his back to the camera and pretend to adjust his monocle just to hide the fact that he was turning bright red from suppressed giggles.

The wardrobe ladies came out with safety pins and a new belt, looking like a pit crew at a race track, trying to rebuild John’s wardrobe while he stood there eating a piece of strudel someone had handed him to calm his nerves.

He was standing there in his thermal underwear, wearing his helmet and his medals, calmly munching on pastry while three women pinned his pants back together.

It was the most absurd thing I have ever seen in my life.

That was the magic of John, though.

He knew how ridiculous the whole situation was—us, the show, the costumes.

He used that moment to break the tension of a very long, very cold work week.

He later confessed to me in his trailer that he had felt the belt straining during rehearsal, but he figured he could “outrun the physics of it” for one take.

He was wrong, of course, but that mistake became one of those legendary stories that we would tell at every cast dinner for years.

It reminded us that no matter how serious the scene or how heavy the history we were playing with, we were just men in costumes trying to make people smile.

Whenever I see a clip of him now, stumbling through a scene with that “I see nothing” line, I don’t see a bumbling guard.

I see my friend John, standing in the snow in his long johns, making an entire film crew forget their exhaustion for a few wonderful minutes.

We didn’t just make a show; we made a family, and families are built on the moments where everything falls apart.

Sometimes, the best way to handle a total collapse is to just stand there and admit you see nothing.

It certainly worked for John, and it’s a philosophy that hasn’t failed me yet.

Is there a specific TV show memory that always makes you laugh no matter how many times you hear it?

Related Posts

THE FLYING MONOCLE AND THE STOIC GENERAL OF STALAG 13

The interviewer’s office is filled with the kind of soft, golden light that only seems to exist in late-afternoon California. Werner Klemperer sits across from me, looking remarkably…

THE DAY THE TERRIFYING SERGEANT SCHULTZ FELL APART

I was sitting in a small, wood-paneled radio booth in Los Angeles back in the late nineties, doing one of those retrospective interviews that actors of a certain…

WE LAUGHED BEHIND THE BARBED WIRE… UNTIL THE MUSIC STOPPED

The sun was setting over the backlot of 40 Acres in Culver City, casting long, skeletal shadows across the dust. It was years after the cameras had stopped…

THE DAY SERGEANT SCHULTZ FINALLY ADMITTED TO SEEING EVERYTHING

The late-night talk show set was quiet, the smell of floor wax and stale coffee lingering in the air. John Banner sat back in the leather chair, his…

THE DAY JOHN BANNER FINALLY SAW EVERYTHING ON SET

The studio light reflects off the mahogany table as Robert Clary settles into his chair. He is in his late eighties now, but the spark in his eyes…

THE COMMANDANT CONDUCTS A SYMPHONY OF UNEXPECTED LAUGHTER

The studio lights were dim, the kind of amber glow you only see on late-night talk shows in the early nineties. Werner Klemperer sat there, looking every bit…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *