
It is a funny thing about memory, isn’t it?
You spend years trying to build a career based on gravitas and classical training, and yet, the things that stick to the ribs of your soul are the moments where you completely lost your dignity.
I was sitting in a studio recently for a retrospective podcast, the kind where the host is much younger than the show itself, and they asked me something I wasn’t quite prepared for.
They didn’t ask about the Emmy nominations or the technical difficulty of the surgical scenes in the OR.
They asked, “David, who was the one person who could make you break character with just a look?”
I didn’t even have to pause.
I just started laughing, right there in the recording booth, because the image of Harry Morgan’s face immediately flashed into my mind.
To the world, Harry was Colonel Sherman Potter—stern, fatherly, the bedrock of the 4077th.
But to those of us on Stage 9, Harry was a lethal weapon of comedy.
He was a man who possessed a brand of mischief that was so quiet, so subtle, that you never saw the strike coming until you were already drowning in laughter.
There was this one particular Tuesday.
The air in the studio was thick and stale, that classic Fox Stage 9 atmosphere where the dust of three decades seems to settle in your lungs.
We were filming a scene in the mess hall, and for those who remember Major Charles Emerson Winchester III, you know he wasn’t exactly a man of brevity.
I had this incredibly long, incredibly pompous monologue about the lack of decent upholstery in the camp, or perhaps it was the lack of a proper Bordeaux.
Winchester was in full, arrogant bloom.
I had been practicing the cadence for hours, making sure every “thee-ah-tuh” and “how-ev-ah” was perfectly enunciated.
The camera was tight on my face for a close-up, and Harry was sitting directly across from me, just out of the primary frame but very much in my line of sight.
He was supposed to be eating his “Sloppy Joe” and looking weary of my complaining.
We had been at it for twelve hours.
The lights were hot, the crew was exhausted, and everyone just wanted to go home.
I reached the crescendo of my speech, that moment where Charles is at his most insufferable.
I took a deep breath, looked Harry straight in the eye to deliver the final, biting insult of the paragraph.
And that’s when it happened.
Harry didn’t say a word.
He didn’t even move his head.
But as I reached the climax of my high-brow indignation, Harry slowly, and with the precision of a master surgeon, began to vibrate his ears.
Not just a twitch, mind you.
It was a rhythmic, independent pulsing of the ears that seemed to defy the laws of human anatomy.
And then, while his ears were doing this bizarre dance, he very slowly crossed his eyes—not all the way, just enough so that he looked like a man who had suddenly seen a ghost sitting on the bridge of his own nose.
The silence in my head was instantaneous.
My brain, which had been working so hard to maintain the Bostonian accent and the aristocratic posture, simply short-circuited.
I tried to push through.
I really did.
I got out the words “The sheer audacity of this—” and then my voice just turned into a high-pitched squeak.
It sounded like a balloon losing air in a cathedral.
I looked at Harry, hoping for a shred of professional mercy, but he just sat there with that cross-eyed, ear-wiggling expression, looking like a deranged owl.
I exploded.
It wasn’t just a chuckle; it was a full-body, soul-cleansing convulsion of laughter.
I fell forward, my head hitting the mess hall table with a loud thud, and I couldn’t breathe.
When I finally managed to look up, I saw the “contagion” taking hold.
Alan Alda, who was standing nearby, saw my face and immediately lost his own composure.
Then Mike Farrell started.
But the best part was the crew.
You have to understand, the camera operators have seen everything.
They are the most cynical, hardened professionals in Hollywood.
I looked over and the camera was literally shaking.
The operator had his head buried in his arm, his shoulders heaving in total silence.
Our director, I believe it was Burt Metcalfe that day, called “Cut,” but he wasn’t angry.
He couldn’t be.
He was leaning against the script supervisor’s desk, wiping tears from his eyes.
“David,” he gasped, “can we please just get one take where you don’t look like you’re having a seizure?”
We tried.
Oh, we tried so hard.
We reset the lights.
I walked outside, breathed the fresh air, and told myself, “You are a professional. You have performed Shakespeare. You can handle Harry Morgan.”
I walked back in.
Positions.
“Action!”
I started the monologue again.
I was doing beautifully.
I was even better than the first time.
I felt the power of the character returning.
I reached the same spot, that final biting line.
I deliberately looked slightly above Harry’s head so I wouldn’t see his face.
But Harry knew.
He didn’t do the ears this time.
Instead, he made this tiny, microscopic “pfft” sound with his lips, like a very small, very polite cricket.
That was it.
The set was done for the day.
I think we spent the next forty-five minutes in a state of collective hysteria.
Every time I looked at Harry, he would give me this look of wounded innocence, as if to say, “Me? I’m just a colonel eating my lunch. Whatever is the matter with you, David?”
That was the magic of that set.
We were telling stories about war, about the most horrific conditions imaginable, and sometimes the only way to survive the weight of that was to lean into the absolute absurdity of being grown men in olive drab playing pretend.
Harry taught me that.
He taught me that you can be the most professional actor in the room and still be the biggest child.
He knew exactly when we needed to break.
He knew when the tension was too high and we needed to remember that we were, fundamentally, a family of clowns.
I think about that day every time I see a rerun of that episode.
I can see the exact moment in the final cut—because they did eventually get a take—where my eyes are just a little bit too bright and my lip is twitching just a fraction.
The audience sees Winchester being pompous.
But I see a man who is one second away from falling off his chair because a 70-year-old legend was wiggling his ears at him.
It’s a lovely way to remember a friend.
It’s a reminder that even in the most serious of roles, there is always room for a little bit of “Sloppy Joe” induced madness.
I wouldn’t trade those wasted takes for all the Emmys in the world.
What’s a moment from your own life where you couldn’t stop laughing at the absolute worst time?