
It was one of those quiet, sun-drenched afternoons in a Los Angeles recording studio where the past feels more tangible than the present.
David Ogden Stiers sat across from the interviewer, his posture still possessing that regal, almost intimidating stiffness that defined Charles Emerson Winchester III.
His voice, however, was warm and resonant, lacking the sharp, aristocratic bite of the man he played for so many years on MAS*H.
The interviewer leaned forward, checking a note on a legal pad, and asked a question that seemed to trigger something behind David’s eyes.
“David, everyone talks about the comedy on screen, but who was the one person who could actually make you break character when the cameras were rolling?”
David laughed, a deep, musical sound that filled the small room, and he leaned back, shaking his head as if he were already seeing the scene play out in his mind.
He explained that while the world saw Harry Morgan as the stern, disciplined Colonel Sherman T. Potter, the cast knew him as something entirely different.
To them, Harry was the “Great Corrupter,” a man who took a perverse, joyful delight in dismantling the professionalism of his co-stars.
David recalled a specific afternoon toward the end of the series, filming a scene in the cramped, dusty confines of the Swamp.
The set was hot, the crew was exhausted, and everyone was anxious to wrap up a particularly long day of filming.
The script called for Winchester to deliver a long, incredibly pompous monologue about the cultural vacuum of Korea compared to the refined air of Boston.
It was a classic Winchester moment, filled with multi-syllabic words and a sense of unearned superiority.
Harry Morgan, as Colonel Potter, was supposed to be sitting across from him, listening with his usual stoic, slightly annoyed patience.
The director wanted a tight close-up on David, which meant the camera was inches from his face, capturing every subtle twitch of his expression.
David took a deep breath, centered his thoughts on the New England Philharmonic, and prepared to be the most arrogant man in the 4077th.
He looked Harry directly in the eye, and for the first few lines, everything was going perfectly.
The dialogue was flowing, the tone was just right, and David felt completely locked into the character’s high-born frustration.
But then, out of the corner of his eye, David noticed a slight movement from Harry that wasn’t in the rehearsal.
Harry was still looking at him with that steady, commanding Colonel Potter gaze, but his expression began to shift ever so slightly into something else.
David felt a cold prickle of realization that he was being hunted by a master of comedic timing.
He tried to focus on his next line, a complex sentence about the historical significance of his family’s estate.
And that’s when it happened.
Underneath the small, cluttered wooden table that sat between them, Harry Morgan had quietly and stealthily slipped off his right combat boot.
As David reached the most dramatic part of his speech, his voice dripping with theatrical disdain, he felt something warm and strangely rhythmic press against his shin.
Harry had extended his bare foot across the gap and was now very deliberately, and very slowly, stroking David’s leg with his big toe.
David’s brain experienced a momentary, catastrophic short-circuit.
He was mid-sentence, talking about the “refined sensibilities of the Charles River,” while a seventy-year-old man was playing footsie with him under the table.
He looked into Harry’s eyes, searching for a sign of a joke or a wink, but there was nothing.
Harry Morgan was giving the performance of a lifetime, looking like the most professional, serious commanding officer in the United States Army.
His face was a mask of stone, but beneath that mask, his toe was performing a rhythmic, insistent dance against David’s calf.
David felt the first bubble of a laugh rising in his chest, a desperate, frantic thing that he tried to crush with sheer willpower.
He stuttered, his Boston accent wavering for a fraction of a second, but he managed to push through to the next sentence.
The director, unaware of the clandestine activity happening below the frame, whispered a quiet “Beautiful” from behind the monitor.
Encouraged by David’s struggle, Harry upped the ante.
He didn’t just stroke the leg anymore; he began to use his toes to gently pinch the fabric of David’s trousers, tugging on them in a way that was both subtle and maddeningly hilarious.
Then, Harry’s face changed.
He didn’t break into a smile, but he widened his eyes just a fraction of a millimeter and let his lower lip tremble, as if he were about to burst into tears of pure, concentrated mischief.
David hit the final line of the monologue, but as the word “Boston” left his lips, it came out as a strangled, high-pitched squeak.
He absolutely exploded.
The laughter was so sudden and so violent that David actually doubled over, his head nearly hitting the table.
The director yelled “Cut!” with a tone of utter confusion, looking around the set to see what had gone wrong.
“David? What happened? That was a perfect take until the very end,” the director asked, stepping into the light.
David couldn’t even speak; he just pointed a trembling finger toward the floor.
Harry Morgan, meanwhile, had already pulled his foot back and was sitting there with an expression of pure, angelic innocence.
“Is something wrong, David?” Harry asked, his voice sounding like a concerned grandfather. “Are you feeling quite well?”
The crew was silent for a moment, watching David struggle to catch his breath, and then Harry let out a tiny, mischievous “Heh” that broke the dam.
When the director finally looked under the table and saw Harry’s bare foot resting on top of his boot, the entire set disintegrated.
The cameraman, who had been trying to stay professional, started shaking so hard that the camera actually tilted off its axis.
The sound engineer took off his headphones and just sat down on a crate, laughing into his hands.
They tried to reset the scene, but the damage was done.
Every time David looked at Harry, he saw the “toe” in his mind’s eye, and he would start giggling all over again.
They went through four more takes, and each one failed earlier than the last.
In take three, Harry didn’t even use his foot; he just looked at David and did a very slow, deliberate blink with one eye.
David was gone before he could even finish the first sentence.
By take five, the director was laughing along with them, realizing that the “Great Corrupter” had claimed another victim and there was no point in fighting it.
They eventually had to film David’s close-up while Harry was standing behind the camera, out of sight, just so David could get through the lines without losing his mind.
David told the interviewer that it was the most unprofessional he had ever been in his entire career, and yet, it was his favorite memory of the show.
He realized that day that Harry wasn’t trying to ruin the scene; he was trying to keep the spirit of the cast alive during a grueling production schedule.
It was a reminder that even in the middle of a serious show about a serious war, there was always room for a bare toe and a bit of nonsense.
Harry Morgan had a way of reminding everyone that they were a family, and families, above all else, know how to push each other’s buttons.
David leaned back in his chair in the studio, the memory clearly bringing him a profound sense of joy decades later.
He said he never looked at Colonel Potter the same way again, and every time he saw that episode in reruns, he could still feel that toe on his shin.
It was a small, ridiculous moment that became a legendary story among the cast and crew, a testament to the man Harry Morgan really was.
Behind the medals and the stern commands was a man who just wanted to see if he could make a Boston aristocrat crack a smile.
And in the end, he did much more than that; he made him lose his dignity in the most wonderful way possible.
Do you have a favorite MAS*H character who always seemed like they were holding back a laugh?